Extra Soft Amish-made Mattresses

Some sleepers want to sink in, and that deep, cloud-like feel is exactly the point. Monarch Rest Extra Plush mattresses rate 1 to 2 on an 8-point firmness scale, the softest we offer, built for pressure relief and contouring around the shoulders and hips. That makes them a natural fit for side sleepers and anyone who prefers sleeping in a mattress rather than on top of it. The comfort layers lead with gel-infused memory foam that helps dissipate heat and breathable Talalay latex for responsive softness. The Integrity line pairs those plush layers with independent pocket coils to isolate motion, while the Perfect Choice series adds a replaceable topper system so you can adjust the feel as your preferences change. Every Monarch Rest mattress is handcrafted in Sugarcreek, Ohio and backed by a 20-year warranty. Browse our Extra Plush mattresses below for sleepers who like to sink in.